Located @ The Vogue
In the Heart of St. Matthews
Gifts for Babies, Brides, & Beaus
& Something for you too!
Come see us Today
We^d love to see you!
Meet Windsor
Our official greeter and ambassador
Located at the Vogue Center in the heart of Louisville's St. Matthew's neighborhood,,
From The Vault offers custom jewelry designs, an exciting and eclectic selection of jewelry, hand and machine engraving, along with all manner of jewelry repair.

We also offer retail replacement value appraisals, for your insurance needs.


You might have something specific in mind, or you may leave the design process up to us. Most of the time, you are not going to walk into a store and see a ready made piece that will fit multiple stones of varying sizes... and that's where we come in! We will look to see if we can find something that is pre-made, but if we can't find one, or if the design of the piece isn't what you had in mind, we move on to the next step, a custom design.


Our amazing state of the art machine can provide monograms, logos, crests, really anything you can dream up! On glass, metals, leather, wood or plastic. This hardworking machine is the largest capacity one of its kind on the market, so it can engrave from the tiniest item to large trays, trophies. Of course hand engraving is still available upon request, in all of the traditional styles.


From the Vault offers jewelry repairs done onsite by our experienced jewelers who can take care of all your repair needs. We do everything from ring sizing, to repairing costume jewelry, to heirloom restoration. Our state of the art equipment allows us to precisely repair all types of jewelry. We think outside of the box! Call or come by!


Finding and selecting the perfect ring for your engagement can be a daunting task. There are hundreds, if not thousands of styles to choose from! We offer a small selection of handpicked mountings. While we don't have the largest selection of mountings, we feel like we have a beautiful collection to choose from. Since we also specialize in custom jewelry, we can also create a one of a kind mounting that meets your specific desires. We offer new interactive software to build your dream ring.
Wanamaker Trophy
From the Vault is proud to have engraved the Wanamaker Trophy for the prestigious <strong>PGA Championship</strong> in 2014.<br>The trophy was ultimately presented to Rory McIlroy at the conclusion of the Championship at Valhalla Golf Club.
From the Vault is proud to have engraved the Wanamaker Trophy for the prestigious PGA Championship in 2014.
The trophy was ultimately presented to Rory McIlroy at the conclusion of the Championship at Valhalla Golf Club.
$1,000 Mint Julep
Thank you Brown-Forman for choosing to shop local. From The Vault has been honored to design and produce the $1,000 Julep Cup from 2012-20.
Our Collections
18k Yellow Gold Blue Sapphire and Diamond Cigar Band
Adel Chefridi Stackable Rings – Sterling Silver with Sapphire, Ruby, Diamonds and Aquamarine
18k Yellow Gold Multi-Colored Sapphire Cigar Band
18k Yellow Gold and Amethyst Italian Intaglio Pendant Featuring the Lion from our Handmade Collection
18k Two-Tone Emerald and Diamond Ring –4.15ctw Emeralds &amp; 0.63ctw Diamonds
Stack of 18k Rose Gold Rings – Morganite, Diamond and Mother of Pearl
22k Yellow Gold Ethiopian Opal Bracelet from our Opal Collection
Gift Cards Available – Easy and they always are appreciated
Southern Gates Pendant in Sterling with Turquoise Accent
Luxurious Navy Blue Velvet Embroidered Jewelry Boxes
Handmade Stackable Bands in Rose, Yellow, and White Gold
Artistic Beads for Layering Featuring Labradorite, Peach Moonstone, Carnelian, Garnet, and Pearl
Adel Chefridi Lotus Pendant – Award Winning Design
18k Yellow Gold Carnelian Intaglio Earrings Featuring Cherub with Diamonds and “Family” Intaglio Pinky Ring from our Collection
14k Yellow Gold Hand wrought Sterling Silver Bee Pendant from our “Bee” Collection
Unusual and custom applications available for our mint julep cups – perfect Kentucky gifts
Julie Rofman –Hand loomed, glass infused beaded bracelets and headbands
Classic engravables for children, including the keepsake knife
Customer's Testimonials

What started as a wild idea, with very specific requirements, Graham made happen. I couldn't be more pleased with my pieces
or the experience with this shop. -Chris

I cannot say enough nice things about Graham and the people who work here! My engagement ring is a vintage family heirloom over 100 years old- after going to several other jewelers who said it was too 'delicate' and 'fragile' to work on, Graham immediately said yes and started coming up with ideas to improve the prongs and add our own 'touch' to the ring. He also custom designed my wedding band to perfectly match and compliment my ring! I LOVE them so much. Great company with great customer service, I will NEVER take my ring anywhere else!! -Rachel

Sheila, Graham and everyone are always wonderful. Graham restored my great aunt’s vintage wedding ring to its former glory. Thank you! -Mary

I feel I have developed a real friendship with Sheila and Graham. -Lynn

From the Vault has made me some very fabulous, one-of-a-kind pieces of jewelry that I will cherish for a lifetime! -Karen

Our Team

Sheila Newton



Sheila has diplomas from the Gemological Institute of America, in both Diamonds and Pearls. She has over 40 years of experience in the Gems and Jewelry trade. She is the lead buyer for the store, and her discriminating eye can be seen in each hand-picked item we have in our showcases.

Graham Newton


President, Lead Designer, AiSupervising Appraiser

Graham is the lead designer and lead CAD operator at From the Vault Jewelers. His team can help with any design, custom project, repair or modification. He is an AI Society Accredited Member, having earned the prestigious and advanced designation of “AiS™ Ai Society Accredited Valuer,”and is our AiSupervising Appraiser. We may now provide you with the most advanced Valuation and Valuation Related Services.

Phyllis Hickey


Lead Sales & GIA Gemologist

Phyllis is a talented artist and brings years of experience in the Gems and Jewelry trade to our store. She is a valuable member of our design team, able to assist you with ideas for your custom design. She is our sales lead, as well as our instore GIA trained Gemologist. She is qualified to provide a wide range of Gemological appraisal related services.

Aaron Smith


Jewelry Artisan

Aaron earned his Bachelor’s in Fine Arts from Indiana University, and is a graduate of the prestigious New Approach School for Jewelers. A key member of our shop’s team, Aaron specializes in hand fabrication, advanced stone setting, and advanced laser repairs.

Carolyn Fleming


Jewelry Repair Specialist

Carolyn is a graduate of the Gemological Institute of America’s Jewelry Program, which she earned on GIA’s Carlsbad California campus after her stint in the Navy (thank you for your service!). She brings over 15 years of advanced repair experience. She is a talented wax carver, stone setter, and general repair specialist.

Drop us a Line!
Do you have a burning question, or perhaps you just want to say hello?
We'd love to hear from you!
Use the contact form to send us a message.
We will get back to you as soon as possible.
  • Open: Mon - Fri: 10:00 am - 5:00pm | Sat: 10:00 am - 3:00 pm
  • (502) 893-0900
  • info@finerjewelry.com
Vogue Theater
Located in The Vogue Theater in the heart of St. Matthews.
3720 Frankfort Ave
Louisville, KY 40207
(502) 893-0900
Subscribe to our Newsletter